People with the last name Nicolay in New Jersey
- Annette Nicolay
- Bart Nicolay
- Carol Nicolay
- Carolyn Nicolay
- Constance Nicolay
- Erna Nicolay
- Grace Nicolay
- Greg Nicolay
- Harry Nicolay
- Hartman Nicolay
- Herbert Nicolay
- James Nicolay
- Jennifer Nicolay
- Joseph Nicolay
- Josephine Nicolay
- Joshua Nicolay
- Kristen Nicolay
- Nickolas Nicolay
- Renee Nicolay
- Richard Nicolay
- Samantha Nicolay
- Scott Nicolay
- Shawn Nicolay
- Todd Nicolay
- Tonya Nicolay
- William Nicolay
<1>